{
  "candidate_semantic_successor": null,
  "claims": [
    {
      "claim": "ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY keeps meaning and qualified logic centrally and gives bounded executors only the machine work they must perform.",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "id": "ARCH_001",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "FACTORY_QUALIFIED_SEMANTIC_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": false
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "The human projection is derived from qualified product truth; presentation is not the specification.",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "id": "ARCH_002",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "DIRECT_CAPABILITY_PROOF_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": true,
        "capability_id": "public_human_projection"
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "Missing authority, missing providers and unresolved uncertainty fail closed instead of creating a guessed effect.",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "id": "ARCH_003",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "FACTORY_QUALIFIED_SEMANTIC_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": false
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY binds evidence and receipts cryptographically; evidence does not automatically become semantic truth or effect authority.",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "id": "ARCH_004",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "FACTORY_QUALIFIED_SEMANTIC_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": false
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY can bind a workflow to explicit specifications, inputs, provider identities and evidence receipts.",
      "domain": "science",
      "id": "SCI_001",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "FACTORY_QUALIFIED_SEMANTIC_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": false
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "For the CMS 2012 di-muon v1.4 reference workflow, an ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY blueprint-bound bounded replacement reproduced the qualified legacy numerical result exactly and an independent clean-room rerun reproduced the same 30,000-bin histogram including flow.",
      "domain": "science",
      "id": "SCI_002",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_REAL_REFERENCE_EXPERIMENT",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "DIRECT_CAPABILITY_PROOF_LINEAGE",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": true,
        "capability_id": "science_cms_dimuon_exact_equivalence"
      }
    },
    {
      "claim": "Across two independently qualified CMS Open Data reference workflows with materially different pipeline structures, ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY blueprint-bound bounded replacement providers preserved the qualified numerical outputs under predeclared equivalence contracts and independent clean-room reruns.",
      "domain": "science",
      "id": "SCI_003",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_LIMITED_CROSS_WORKFLOW_REPRODUCIBILITY_CLAIM",
      "scope": {
        "cross_domain_generalization_authorized": false,
        "domain": "CMS_OPEN_DATA_PARTICLE_PHYSICS_ANALYSIS",
        "experiment_count": 2
      },
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "QUALIFIED_CROSS_WORKFLOW_LINEAGE_WITHOUT_DUPLICATED_RECEIPTS",
        "source": "/current-product-truth.json",
        "direct_receipt_binding": false,
        "boundary": "Public projection does not invent a new receipt."
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ARCH_005",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "claim": "ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY qualifies runtime replacement against declared bytes, materialized filesystem bytes, active process identity, required parent/child lifecycle and full-surface reobservation; partial behavior alone is not a replacement PASS.",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY_V642",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "DIRECT_FACTORY_PATTERN_LINEAGE",
        "contract_sha256": "fda1eee6412202ed6cdfc72217ebd4a71bf38b8f9c99b7618a65473a152518eb",
        "pattern_sha256": "ccfaeadea28aaa7e43d3ac40935d24bf85b4c5276ced14111fc4c2a05a91d858",
        "counterexample_experience_sha256": "cd3a8f400add5c3d5793f7606eb57b429fc4c90ecdeecf7088269c2baebb8940",
        "qualification_receipt_sha256": "2ac516af66ca13d4077c69f99555a0634a61b7c05cfad17adf6af1eb9c546904",
        "direct_receipt_binding": true
      }
    },
    {
      "id": "ARCH_006",
      "domain": "architecture",
      "claim": "ATLAS_EVOLUTION_FACTORY keeps observation and status state outside the identity basis of the artifact being observed, so requalification can advance without renaming unchanged artifact meaning.",
      "qualification": "QUALIFIED_BY_CURRENT_FACTORY_V643",
      "evidence_lineage": {
        "state": "DIRECT_FACTORY_PATTERN_LINEAGE",
        "contract_sha256": "de7051f8dba3aa9ea756359ab29b9728d62cc06eee1dd90fbf197b3e6eabe6c8",
        "pattern_sha256": "ec900becef6e8b8091364d5ffec9035774694c95afea3072498023e667ebac73",
        "qualification_receipt_sha256": "13d751f8aabc09bd3c5a9e6a21b2c37f0c87b3cb9c92c0a02a75205a6c131cac",
        "direct_receipt_binding": true
      },
      "boundary": "Stable artifact members or identity-basis changes still require a new identity."
    }
  ],
  "current_product_truth_route": "/current-product-truth.json",
  "decision": "FACTORY_V643_REVALIDATED_QUALIFIED_PUBLIC_CLAIMS",
  "effect_authority": false,
  "explicit_non_claims": [
    "Vision statements are not current Product Truth.",
    "Pattern observation does not automatically promote semantic truth or production effects.",
    "Community citizen status grants no semantic or effect authority.",
    "Semantic condensation is a design direction, not a proof that irreducible special cases can never exist."
  ],
  "factory_baseline": "v641",
  "factory_truth_binding": {
    "binding_state": "CURRENT_ROOT_BOUND",
    "factory_version": "v643",
    "gar_sha256": "cc842cfc36948072491cf774ae53c6b5ca4ff93684f1e51cc10ea0de87e39533",
    "root_authority_sha256": "6e54f9c02c24d00b2ad9554b0aedf14c7359b7ce1cdb2975ec5d55980ccfad7d"
  },
  "maturity_boundary_rule": "Claims do not imply public-live capability state; consult Factory-derived current Product Truth.",
  "omission_rule": "HYPOTHESES_ASPIRATIONAL_OR_REJECTED_CLAIMS_ARE_NOT_PROJECTED_AS_PRODUCT_FACTS",
  "projection_freshness": "CURRENT_ROOT_BOUND",
  "revalidation": {
    "claim_semantics_changed": false,
    "maturity_or_boundary_upgraded": false,
    "previous_factory_baseline": "v629",
    "rule": "rebind_without_claim_upgrade"
  },
  "schema": "atlas.public.qualified_claims.v1.machine.json",
  "semantic_truth_authority": false,
  "evidence_lineage_rule": "Reference canonical Product Truth/proof lineage; do not duplicate or invent evidence receipts in claim projection.",
  "evidence_lineage_coverage": {
    "claims_total": 8,
    "direct_capability_proof_lineage": 2,
    "invented_receipts": 0
  }
}