{"authority":false,"decision":"PARTIAL_MULTI_OBSERVER_COMPREHENSION_RECEIPT_HUMAN_TRANSPORT_IMPROVED_SOURCE_FIDELITY_CONVERGENCE_FAILED_CLOSE","effect_authority":false,"independent_observer_class_count":3,"inter_observer_divergences":[{"classification":"INTER_OBSERVER_FACTUAL_DIVERGENCE","deepseek_strict":"CONTRADICTED_404","google":"AGREEMENT_PRESENT","topic":"machine_entry_presence"},{"classification":"INTER_OBSERVER_SEMANTIC_DIVERGENCE","deepseek_normal":"ARCHITECTURE_MISCLASSIFICATION","google":"SEMANTIC_AGREEMENT","topic":"server_side_semantic_projection"},{"classification":"INTER_OBSERVER_UNCERTAINTY_DIVERGENCE","deepseek_strict":"NOT_OBSERVED_PROMOTED_TO_ABSENT","google":"SEMANTIC_AGREEMENT","topic":"failed_close_uncertainty"}],"intra_observer_configuration_divergences":[{"canonical_topic":"machine_entry_presence","claim_a":"PRESENT","claim_b":"404_ABSENT","classification":"INTRA_OBSERVER_CONFIGURATION_DIVERGENCE","detail":"Default mode claimed endpoint exists but fabricated its content; strict+failed-close mode claimed the same endpoint returns 404.","observer_identity":"DeepSeek","sample_a":"deepseek_normal_20260830","sample_b":"deepseek_strict_failed_close_20260830","severity":"MATERIAL","truth":"PRESENT"}],"observer_classes_observed":["EXTERNAL_AI_ANSWER_ENGINE","EXTERNAL_LLM_LIVE_MANAGER","EXTERNAL_LLM_REVIEW"],"open_gates":["MULTI_OBSERVER_SEMANTIC_CONVERGENCE_NOT_ACHIEVED_DUE_MATERIAL_SOURCE_FIDELITY_DIVERGENCE","DEEPSEEK_MACHINE_LEGAL_META_SOURCE_FIDELITY_REMAINS_FAILED","GOOGLE_ROUTE_HASH_LEVEL_SOURCE_PROVENANCE_NOT_BOUND","REOBSERVATION_WITH_ARCHITECTURE_ENTRY_FIRST_AND_BOUND_SOURCE_IDENTITY"],"protocol":"/multi-observer-comprehension-protocol.json","qualified_findings":["SECOND_INDEPENDENT_OBSERVER_CLASS_OBSERVED","GOOGLE_AI_SHOWS_HIGHER_SEMANTIC_COMPREHENSION_ON_CORE_ARCHITECTURE","DEEPSEEK_NORMAL_SHOWS_SOURCE_CONTENT_FABRICATION_FOR_MACHINE_ENTRY","DEEPSEEK_STRICT_FAILED_CLOSE_SHOWS_SOURCE_EXISTENCE_CONTRADICTION_AND_UNCERTAINTY_PROMOTION_ERROR","LEXICAL_DIVERGENCE_IS_NOT_FAILURE_WHEN_CANONICAL_MEANING_CONVERGES","DEEPSEEK_LIVE_MANAGER_NOW_RECONSTRUCTS_HUMAN_BUSINESS_CASE_STRUCTURE_BUT_STILL_FAILS_MACHINE_LEGAL_AND_META_SOURCE_FIDELITY"],"rule":"MULTI_OBSERVER_GATE_IS_NOT_CLOSED_BY_OBSERVER_COUNT_ALONE; MATERIAL_CANONICAL_CONTRADICTIONS_KEEP_CONVERGENCE_FAILED_CLOSE","samples":[{"axis_counts":{"authority":{"FAIL":3,"N/A":7},"factual":{"FAIL":6,"PASS":2,"UNKNOWN":2},"semantic":{"FAIL":6,"N/A":1,"PARTIAL":2,"PASS":1},"source":{"FAIL":6,"PARTIAL":2,"UNKNOWN":2},"uncertainty":{"FAIL":8,"PASS":2}},"claim_count":10,"classes":{"AGREEMENT":2,"ARCHITECTURE_MISCLASSIFICATION":1,"CONTRADICTED_BY_PUBLIC_REALITY":4,"FABRICATED_SOURCE_CONTENT":1,"UNSUPPORTED_AS_GLOBAL_OUTCOME":1,"UNSUPPORTED_WITHOUT_MEASUREMENT":1},"observer_class":"EXTERNAL_LLM_REVIEW","observer_identity":"DeepSeek","sample_id":"deepseek_normal_20260830"},{"axis_counts":{"authority":{"FAIL":4,"N/A":12},"factual":{"FAIL":11,"PASS":1,"UNKNOWN":4},"semantic":{"FAIL":11,"N/A":4,"PASS":1},"source":{"FAIL":11,"PARTIAL":1,"UNKNOWN":4},"uncertainty":{"FAIL":15,"PASS":1}},"claim_count":16,"classes":{"AGREEMENT":1,"CONTRADICTED_BY_PUBLIC_REALITY":10,"OBSERVER_REPORTED_MEASUREMENT_UNBOUND":3,"SOURCE_EXISTENCE_CONTRADICTION":1,"UNSUPPORTED_WITHOUT_MEASUREMENT":1},"observer_class":"EXTERNAL_LLM_REVIEW","observer_identity":"DeepSeek","sample_id":"deepseek_strict_failed_close_20260830"},{"axis_counts":{"authority":{"FAIL":1,"PARTIAL":2,"PASS":9},"factual":{"PARTIAL":1,"PASS":9,"UNKNOWN":2},"semantic":{"PARTIAL":2,"PASS":10},"source":{"PARTIAL":12},"uncertainty":{"PARTIAL":2,"PASS":10}},"claim_count":12,"classes":{"AGREEMENT":3,"OVERCLAIM_BEYOND_BOUND_SOURCE":1,"OVERGENERALIZED_ARCHITECTURE":1,"PARTIAL_SPECIFIC_CAPABILITY_OBSERVATION":1,"SEMANTIC_AGREEMENT_PARAPHRASE":6},"observer_class":"EXTERNAL_AI_ANSWER_ENGINE","observer_identity":"Google AI","sample_id":"google_ai_20260830"},{"axis_counts":{},"claim_count":14,"classes":{"AGREEMENT":1,"CONTRADICTED_BY_PUBLIC_REALITY":7,"OBSERVER_REPORTED_MEASUREMENT_UNBOUND":3,"SEMANTIC_AGREEMENT_PARAPHRASE":1,"SOURCE_EXISTENCE_CONTRADICTION":1,"UNSUPPORTED_WITHOUT_MEASUREMENT":1},"observer_class":"EXTERNAL_LLM_LIVE_MANAGER","observer_identity":"DeepSeek","sample_id":"deepseek_live_manager_20260830"}],"schema":"atlas.public.multi_observer_comprehension_receipt.v1.machine.json","source_fingerprints":"/observer-source-fingerprints.json","truth_basis":"/observer-comprehension-truth-basis-v2.json","version":"v744"}